NASA’s Big Mistake: LIGO’s Merging Black Holes Were Invisible After All (Synopsis) [Starts With A Bang]


“What’s really exciting is what comes next. I think we’re opening a window on the universe — a window of gravitational wave astronomy.” -Dave Reitze

On September 14, 2015, LIGO directly detected gravitational waves for the first time, from the inspiral-and-merger of two quite massive black holes. Despite the fact that no electromagnetic radiation signal was expected, the Fermi GBM instrument measured a high-energy X-ray event just 0.4 seconds after LIGO’s 200 millisecond detection occurred. According to NASA scientists working on the Fermi mission, there was just a 0.2% chance of a false positive.

Image credit: ESA–C.Carreau, of the "ripple" effect on spacetime that a passing gravitational wave imparts.

Image credit: ESA–C.Carreau, of the “ripple” effect on spacetime that a passing gravitational wave imparts.

In a new paper out today, however, a reanalysis using a superior statistical method shows that the 0.2% chance is, in fact, true, and that LIGO’s black holes didn’t have an electromagnetic counterpart after all. This new statistical technique will be incredibly useful down the road for discriminating between robust astrophysical signals and spikes in the noise that have hitherto been a source of incredible confusion.

Various statistical techniques analyzing the Fermi data. The original analysis (purple) shows a signal, but the improved analysis (orange) shows only something consistent with pure noise. Image credit: Figure 5 from J. Greiner, J.M. Burgess, V. Savchenko and H.-F. Yu, retrieved from the preprint at http://ift.tt/1Ui4E54.

Various statistical techniques analyzing the Fermi data. The original analysis (purple) shows a signal, but the improved analysis (orange) shows only something consistent with pure noise. Image credit: Figure 5 from J. Greiner, J.M. Burgess, V. Savchenko and H.-F. Yu, retrieved from the preprint at http://ift.tt/1Ui4E54.

Go get the full story on the latest development in understanding the very first directly detected gravitational wave!



from ScienceBlogs http://ift.tt/1sRZ830

“What’s really exciting is what comes next. I think we’re opening a window on the universe — a window of gravitational wave astronomy.” -Dave Reitze

On September 14, 2015, LIGO directly detected gravitational waves for the first time, from the inspiral-and-merger of two quite massive black holes. Despite the fact that no electromagnetic radiation signal was expected, the Fermi GBM instrument measured a high-energy X-ray event just 0.4 seconds after LIGO’s 200 millisecond detection occurred. According to NASA scientists working on the Fermi mission, there was just a 0.2% chance of a false positive.

Image credit: ESA–C.Carreau, of the "ripple" effect on spacetime that a passing gravitational wave imparts.

Image credit: ESA–C.Carreau, of the “ripple” effect on spacetime that a passing gravitational wave imparts.

In a new paper out today, however, a reanalysis using a superior statistical method shows that the 0.2% chance is, in fact, true, and that LIGO’s black holes didn’t have an electromagnetic counterpart after all. This new statistical technique will be incredibly useful down the road for discriminating between robust astrophysical signals and spikes in the noise that have hitherto been a source of incredible confusion.

Various statistical techniques analyzing the Fermi data. The original analysis (purple) shows a signal, but the improved analysis (orange) shows only something consistent with pure noise. Image credit: Figure 5 from J. Greiner, J.M. Burgess, V. Savchenko and H.-F. Yu, retrieved from the preprint at http://ift.tt/1Ui4E54.

Various statistical techniques analyzing the Fermi data. The original analysis (purple) shows a signal, but the improved analysis (orange) shows only something consistent with pure noise. Image credit: Figure 5 from J. Greiner, J.M. Burgess, V. Savchenko and H.-F. Yu, retrieved from the preprint at http://ift.tt/1Ui4E54.

Go get the full story on the latest development in understanding the very first directly detected gravitational wave!



from ScienceBlogs http://ift.tt/1sRZ830

Aucun commentaire:

Enregistrer un commentaire